Economic Development Drives World-Wide Overfishing
Kiel researchers have demonstrated: Only sustainable management can prevent the future collapse of wild stocks; an expansion of aquaculture has only a limited effect.
Cod is among the most popular edible fish in Germany and Europe – the picture is of a young cod. Image: Catriona Clemmesen-Bockelmann, GEOMAR
Photo to download: www.uni-kiel.de/download/pm/2015/2015-305-1.jpg
Stocks of wild fish cannot be protected from overfishing in the long term by the expansion of aquaculture alone. Economic driving forces such as increasing global demand for fish or improved fishing methods will lead in future to increased fishery pressure on the most popular types of edible fish. Ocean researchers from Kiel and Finland come to this conclusion in a current study, which will be published online yesterday (September 8th) in the journal "Global Change Biology".
Economists, fisheries and evolutionary biologists from Kiel University, the GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel, and the Finnish University of Helsinki working together in an interdisciplinary project have calculated how fishery and aquaculture will develop in the coming decades in regard to popular types of edible fish such as sea bass, salmon, cod and tuna. These four are among the most important fish species on the North American and European markets. Salmon and sea bass come mostly from fish farming, while cod and tuna stem from wild-capture fisheries.
The focus of the study was the question of how wild fish stocks will develop up to the year 2048 and beyond. The authors take into account here not only biological influencing factors but also especially how future economic developments will affect fisheries. The researchers simulated particularly technical progress in fisheries, increasing global demand for fish and a growing supply of fish from aquaculture. In addition the study examined the interrelation of these factors in various scenarios with limited effectiveness of regulation on wild fisheries.
“A realistic projection of the future development of economically important wild fish populations can only be reached if, in addition to biological factors we also take into account economic driving forces. The result surprised us, as the economic development had a much stronger influence on the fish stocks than we had expected,” says first author Prof. Martin Quaas from the Institute of Economics at Kiel University and head of the research group “Sustainable Fisheries” in the Cluster of Excellence “The Future Ocean.”
Increasing aquaculture production can relieve wild fish stocks; however this positive effect will probably be overwhelmed by a greater demand and technological progress in the fishing industry – both increasing the fishing pressure on wild stocks. Under present conditions aquaculture production would have to increase by 15 to 24 percent in order to sustain stocks – an unrealistically high amount from the point of view of the researchers. Added to that is the problem that fish from aquaculture is often fed with fish from wild capture. “Even if we were to set very optimistic rates and raise the amount of vegetable protein in the feed, the pressure on fisheries and fish stocks would increase enormously and likely cause their collapse”, says co-author Thorsten Reusch from GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel. Sustainable use of wild fish stocks could however be achieved by means of a considerable increase in the effectiveness of fisheries management, far above today’s standard.
In order to prevent the collapse of the fish stocks the researchers therefore see the only solution as institutional change, which considerably improves the effectiveness of fisheries management for wild fish species. The researchers consider the most recent reforms of the fisheries policy of the European Union a step in the right direction. In the course of the reforms agreed upon in 2013, for example, multiple-year management plans should be introduced for further stocks. In addition strict landing obligations shall be introduced. The researchers see particular need for action for high seas fisheries, including a significantly improved international coordination in determining and enforcing restrictive catch quotas.
Quaas, Martin F., Reusch, Thorsten B. H., Schmidt, Jörn O., Tahvonen, Olli, Voss, Rudi: It is the economy, stupid! Projecting the fate of fish populations using ecological–economic modeling. Global Change Biology (2015), doi: 10.1111/gcb.13060. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/gcb.13060/abstract
Click to enlarge
Aquaculture facilities near the coast of the Faroe Islands. Image: Jan Steffen, GEOMAR
Image to download:
Click to enlarge
Limits of sustainability: Combinations of the effectiveness of wild fish stock regulation and yearly aquaculture production growth rates that could lead to sustainable stock development.
English graph here
Credit: Martin Quaas
Image to download:
Kiel University, Institute of Economics, www.eree.uni-kiel.de/en
GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel, Research Division Marine Ecology,
The Cluster of Excellence “The Future Ocean”, www.futureocean.org/en
Prof. Martin Quaas
Institute of Economics, Kiel University
Prof. Thorsten Reusch
Research Division Marine Ecology / Evolutionary Ecology of Marine Fish
phone: 0431 600 4550
Public Outreach, The Cluster of Excellence “The Future Ocean”
Press, Communication and Marketing, Dr. Boris Pawlowski
Address: D-24098 Kiel, phone: +49 (0431) 880-2104, fax: +49 (0431) 880-1355
email: ► firstname.lastname@example.org, Internet: ► www.uni-kiel.de, Jubiläum: ► www.uni-kiel.de/cau350
Twitter: ► www.twitter.com/kieluni, Facebook: ► www.facebook.com/kieluni
text: Friederike Balzereit